The Lottery and Its Critics
In its simplest form, Lottery is a game in which people pay a small amount of money for a chance to win a large prize based on random selection. The prize is generally cash or a variety of goods and services. In addition to the gaming element, Lottery is also used as a means of raising money for public purposes such as education and charitable causes.
Although the drawing of lots for making decisions and determining fates has a long history (including several instances in the Bible), the modern state-sponsored Lottery is comparatively new. It has a relatively narrow scope of operations and a limited number of games, and it relies on continuous growth in ticket sales for most of its revenue.
As a result, it must advertise and otherwise promote gambling, and critics charge that this puts the Lottery at cross-purposes with the state’s duty to protect the public welfare. In particular, Lottery advertising allegedly promotes addictive gambling behavior, attracts problem gamblers, and contributes to poverty, crime, and other social problems. Some states have a policy of limiting the expenditure of lottery proceeds for certain purposes such as education, but most do not prohibit the use of these funds altogether.
Moreover, state officials overseeing the Lottery tend to be at loggerheads with general public opinion about its appropriate role. They are often pressured by special interests, such as convenience store owners (the main vendors of tickets); suppliers (heavy contributors to state political campaigns are routinely reported); teachers (in those states in which Lottery revenues are earmarked for education); and legislators who have become accustomed to the extra income from Lottery revenues.
The result is that Lottery profits grow at a much faster rate than state government revenues overall, and some legislators see no alternative but to continue increasing the Lottery’s budget and expanding its offerings, even when they think these changes may be harmful to the public. Some critics also object to the alleged ethical conflicts involved in running a public business based on gambling, which is considered a vice by most legal scholars and religious leaders.
Another problem with the Lottery is that the way in which it distributes its prizes undermines its original purpose. By relying on a system of randomly selected numbers, the Lottery encourages the use of luck as the primary determinant of one’s fortune, and thus is incompatible with ethical principles.
Finally, Lottery revenues are often viewed as a regressive tax on lower-income groups, because the Lottery draws people to gambling at rates that disproportionately affect those communities. In addition, studies have shown that participation in the Lottery peaks with middle age and declines with lower incomes. These patterns are consistent with other forms of gambling, which also disproportionately draw participants from middle-income neighborhoods and away from low-income ones.